Translate

Τετάρτη 1 Ιουνίου 2016

PART TWO: Rod Pearce and his Odyssey in Papua New Guinea for WW2 Wrecks and their MIA crews


Rod Pearce has dedicated his time and efforts finding underwater aircraft wrecks and seeking closure to the families of hundreds -if not thousands- of Missing in Action (MIA) airmen from all nations that fought during World War Two.



Here is the second part of his very interesting interview:

When you manage to find an aircraft wreck and identify it, possibly finding out who the pilot was, do you feel like bringing closure to the members of his family?

Oh yes, definitely. Whether it be Japanese, Australian or American it is always a feeling of closure for the family and myself, especially if the aircraft is Australian as I am Australian by birth.




How important is it to preserve those relics for generations to come?

Unfortunately, aircraft in the sea will gradually deteriorate through corrosion, coverage by sand, coral and here in Rabaul volcanic ash, but above all, through human damage, whether it be divers or a ship's anchor.

I would like to see them preserved in some way, even brought up, restored and displayed however the cost of doing this is beyond anyone's dreams.




Because in the next hundred years or so, these will have gone forever or a great majority of them.

The war time ship wrecks are beginning to fall apart through rust and that's only in 70 years.

Having said this, I would like to stress that I am appalled by the practice some (affluent) individuals within the private collector communities employs, by backhanding money to corrupt officials and conning local communities (who often don't know any better) for illegal salvage deals of in-situ aircraft - especially when this is done for personal gain to private collections.



Any such salvage or recovery operation, the way I see it, detracts and contributes to the vanishing heritage of World War II.

In my opinion, aircraft - if salvaged and restored - should be in museums for all to see, and not in some private person's collection.


Do you believe you are raising public awareness to a long gone and perhaps forgotten part of your country's history by finding aircraft wrecks?


Certainly, by raising awareness to the plight of MIA's - that someone actually cares. 

Two cases come to mind VH-CIJ with 19 MIA's found recently in Papua New Guinea and another C47 yet to be found VH-CIZ 22 MIAs, hopefully the awareness will motivate
the authorities into perhaps looking for VH-CIZ. 

The latter one I am beginning to get a feel for but the cost of even mounting a first survey search would be well beyond my means.



Very few people get the opportunity to research, search, find, document and recover those Missing In Action, and to see a project through to completion as in A9-217 was a very rewarding experience, not only for me but for the whole team that worked on the recovery, and of course their families.

Not a lot of people get to experience this sort of feeling of completeness of a job well done.

This by the way is done in conjunction with the authorities and not by me alone.

How many wrecks did you find until now?

This is a very difficult question to answer, due to the fact that I have found aircraft pieces scattered over the bottom - not knowing the type or country it's from.

And these were just pieces, not a complete aircraft. These have obviously blown up in the air, and have been scattered over a wide area.



There are also aircraft I have been looking for but did not find, where I then passed on all the info for others to find, which they have.



For the number of ship wrecks, I'd say four or five,  for smaller boats and barges and such, i haven't even bothered to count there's been so many... 

In one days searching for VH-CIJ we found 15 barges, sunken vessels of all types and over a period of a month while looking for VH-CIJ we found to many to count.

For aircraft wrecks alone, I would have to say 20 to 25 complete aircraft - not counting all the scattered wreckage and debris I have come across - that I could identify as Japanese or Australian: Not all of these wrecks had MIAs onboard.



Most aircraft that ditched in the water, the crews have swam away from. 

They are the lucky ones.

The aircraft in the water usually made a reasonably ditching, so the aircraft is in rather good condition even if there were fatalities on board, like the B24 4123752 at Kawa Island (see www.pacificwrecks.com) 1 MIA still inside, one died of his injuries on the way back to Alotau but the rest of the crew survived.



The aircraft in the bush on the other hand usually went in at high speed, more or less obliterating the planes, and over the years the remains of the aircraft have been reclaimed by the forests, vandalization, animals etc so there is not a lot left.

I have found aircraft on land, in the bush, but I'm not really interested in these, and don't include them in my list of finds. 
I still have on my short list 15 aircraft to find in the water, most with remains and these are very easily findable however; It all comes down to time and money.

And having never been married to anything else than my boat and passion for diving, nor had children, I've been able to direct my surplus into finding wrecks instead.

What are you planning for the next few months? Any wrecks waiting to be located etc?

For the next three months I take off to find a plane in Buka, and then off to Lae to locate an A-20 that ditched with three crew belonging to the RAAF, one of these crewmembers received the Commonwealth's highest reward, the Victoria Cross, and there is still one crewmember MIA on this plane.



This plane is deep, at about 100 meters.

A28-3 a Boston from 22 Squadron is of particular interest to me as my father went to school at Melbourne Grammar with Bill Newton, VC.

How important is it in your opinion to highlight the role of historical warplanes resting on the seabed?

Very important for future generations, to be documented, if not fully, as I have limited resources.

However in the future, someone might like to step up and fully document these aircraft in the form of a documentary or similar.

But for future generations, I think it's a must for them to know what happened, and the relatives of those MIAs know the last resting place of their loved ones.

Could you single out the wreck that made you feel proud of?

A9-217, an Australian Beaufort, which crashed at night off a island in a godforsaken part of New Guinea and all were killed. (see pacificwrecks.com/a9-217)

It was only through my determination and experience in hounding the authorities to do a second recovery that we found all four crewmembers in their entirety.



This, I think, was my most memorable recovery, although I failed to document it properly in the form of pictures, I did write up the report on the recovery and the history of it's last flight.

I should point out, that most - if not all - of the photos on my Facebook-page were taken by other people than me, as I've never been much of an underwater photographer and have always had more than enough to do running my vessel and operating my sonar, in addition to all the research that goes into this type of work.

As such, the photos I've submitted should be credited to the respective photographers, and not myself.

Check more here

Δευτέρα 30 Μαΐου 2016

On this day, May 30, 1941: When two Greeks removed the nazi flag from the Acropolis


It has been acknowledged as one of the first act of resistance against the nazis in Europe and the first in Greece; On this day, in the late hours of May 30, 1941 two young Greeks removed the nazi flag from the Acropolis in Athens. 


Manolis Glezos and Lakis Santas, two young students, climbed on the Acropolis and removed the swastika, which had been there since April 27, 1941, when the Nazi forces had entered Athens. 


It inspired not only the Greeks, but all subjected people, to resist against the occupation, and established them both as two international anti-Nazi heroes. 

The Nazi regime responded by sentencing the perpetrators to death in absentia, but they did not learn who they were until much later. 

Glezos was arrested by the German occupation forces on March 24, 1942, and was subjected to imprisonment and torture. 


As a result of his treatment, he was affected by tuberculosis. He was arrested on April 21, 1943 by the Italian occupation forces and spent three months in jail. 

Greek newspaper "To VIMA" frontpage, dated June 1st, 1941, with a notification on the nazi flag's removal with the "perpetrators to be arrested and sentenced to death" by the German Commander of  Athens.
On February 7, 1944 he was arrested again, this time by Greek nazi collaborators. He spent another seven and a half months in jail, until he finally escaped on September 21 of the same year.

Enquiries are being made, as to the circumstances that lead to the removal of the German flag", according to the Greek daily newspaper "TA NEA", dated early June 1941.

READ MORE HERE



Παρασκευή 27 Μαΐου 2016

The 73 year Odyssey of a lost seaman's family and the submarine lost in 1943



Massimo Domenico Bondone, the experienced Italian deep wreck scuba diver, who is credited with the recent discovery and the identification of the ill-fated British submarine P311 (CLICK TO READ THE FULL STORY) received the following message from Paul Denison, a family member of a lost crew member of the submarine, Able Seaman Leonard Auty:


"Sir on behalf of the family of Able Seaman Leonard Auty, I would like to thank you for finding HMS P311 and the care and respect that you have shown to those that perished. You have my grateful respect."

Giving the lost seamen families' closure, to help them know where they loved ones are after 73 years, is the most important element of this discovery, in my opinion. 

Able Seaman Leonard Auty was born in 1917 and went Missing Presumed Killed with P311 in early January 1943, while on a mission, when he was 26 years old.



Hi family was only given the very barest of details from the Admiralty when he was reported missing.

The last known position of P311 was listed as 38 degrees,10 minutes North,11 degrees 30 Minutes East at 18:30 hrs. on the 30th December in a signal which was received at 01:30 hrs. on the 31st. This was the last signal received from the lost submarine.

Paul Denison stressed that "One thing I will mention, I went to the Royal Navy Memorial at Southsea, as soon as I saw his name my eyes watered and I had to look away and compose myself, quite a reaction for someone that died before I was born."

In an article that was printed on The Times newspaper, Friday, March 12, 1943 (page 4; Issue 49492; col G), under the title Submarine P311 Presumed Lost Commander Cayley's Fine Record published for the first time the loss of the submarine P311.



The article reads as follows:

"The Board of Admiralty regrets to announce the loss of submarine P311 (Commander Richard Douglas Cayley DSO RN) is overdue and must be presumed lost. The next-of-kin have been informed.

Commander Cayley won the DSO and two bars and as one of the outstanding captains of this war. His name will always be associated with HM Submarine Upmost which sunk 69,000 tons of axis shipping in 15 months while he was serving in her. He was 34. 

The loss of Utmost was announced in January. Commander Cayley had for some months previously been in command of P311. 

One of Utmost’s outstanding successes occurred on the night of 21 November 1941. 

Commander Carey sighted three Italian cruisers steaming at 20 knots escorted by destroyers. He attacked on the surface firing his torpedoes at a range of nearly a mile. 

He saw the flash of one torpedo hitting a cruiser just abaft the foremost funnel. Immediately after a great red flame leaped more than 200ft from the stricken ship, the submarine dived to the accompaniment of a violent explosion followed by breaking-up noises. 

In a counter attack which followed 84 depth charges were dropped but the submarine escaped undamaged."

Paul Denison, describes his feelings and his family's Odyssey since 1943 and shows what war is like on a human scale, when you put a name behind a largely forgotten tragedy that haunted the lives of the family members of the lost seamen for 73 years. 


"The loss affected greatly his brother Eric Auty who would never speak about Leonard" Paul says to pierrekosmidis.blogspot.com and adds: 

"We were told that he had been killed in the Royal Navy but that was all we knew. 30 years after his death the family were still coming to terms with it."




Paul Denison is relieved to have found the details of Leonard's loss, back in 1943, with the P311 submarine, thanks to Massimo Domenico Bondone's efforts


Paul goes on describing his thoughts about this family tragedy: 


"About 2003 I stumbled across his name on the war graves commission site, at the time P311 wasn't listed in his details but quick check of submarine losses suggested that P311 was the most likely. 

After checking the Crew list I confirmed that was his submarine so I started looking at the history of the 10th Submarine Flotilla and was amazed at just how much they achieved in hammering Rommel's supply lines."


"There is a sad irony in that the base they were attacking become the home of the 10th Submarine Flotilla only a few months later", Paul adds.


"I believe Leonard left a wife, and son that he had never met. I never knew Leonard but I always wanted to know what happened and I am delighted that their story won't be forgotten."



Just like Leonard's story, millions of families all across the world suffered the lasting trauma of losing a loved one during WW2, sons, brothers, husbands, with no word or details on the whereabouts of their resting place: 

Paul is equally respectful to the losses suffered by both sides during WW2: 

"I did look into the U-boat war, and got passed the propaganda and the tragedy of young men on both sides some of whom probably never will be found.

It saddens me, which is why I am glad that P311 has been found thanks to Massimo Bondone".






Period photos are from the book A Submarine at War: The Brief Life of HMS Trooper By David Grant

Ρ311: Το ιστορικό του εντοπισμού και της ταυτοποίησης του χαμένου υποβρυχίου του Β' Παγκοσμίου Πολέμου, από το δύτη Μάσιμο Ντομένικο Μποντόνε


O Μάσιμο Ντομένικο Μποντόνε, ένας έμπειρος βαθυδύτης και εξερευνητής από την Ιταλία πιστώνεται με ένα ακόμη συναρπαστικό εύρημα, αυτό του ναυαγίου του χαμένου για 73 χρόνια βρετανικού υποβρυχίου Ρ311, η εξαφάνιση του οποίου παρέμενε ένας άλυτος γρίφος για δεκαετίες. 


Ο "Μαξ" πιστώνεται με αρκετά ιστορικά ευρήματα στους βυθούς, όπως το S/S Kreta, κοντά στο νησί Capraia, to Benghasi στη Σαρδηνία και το San Marco στα νερά του Villasimius, μεταξύ άλλων ναυαγίων του Β' Παγκοσμίου Πολέμου. 

Ο Μάσιμο Μποντόνε, με συναδέλφους δύτες (στο μέσον της φωτό)
Το χαμένο για 73 χρόνια, από την εξαφάνισή του τον Ιανουάριο του 1943 βρετανικό υποβρύχιο, βρέθηκε από τον Μποντόνε πριν από λίγες ημέρες και ταυτοποιήθηκε χάρη σε ένα μοναδικό χαρακτηριστικό: τα προσδεδεμένα στο εξωτερικό του κύτους του δύο μίνι-υποβρύχια, που εύκολα μπορούσαν να παρεισφρήσουν στα λιμάνια του εχθρού και να τοποθετήσουν εκρηκτικά στα ύφαλα των πλοίων που ελλιμενίζονταν εκεί.


Τα υποβρύχια αυτά ήταν ακόμα εκεί, συνδεδεμένα στο κύτος του P311 ή "Τουταγχαμών", καθώς αυτό θα ήταν το όνομα που θα "βαφτιζόταν" το υποβρύχιο μετά την επιστροφή του στη βάση υποβρυχίων της Μάλτας. Αυτό θα ήταν το μόνη σκάφος του Βρετανικού Βασιλικού Ναυτικού, που θα έφερε αυτό το όνομα, αλλά δεν πρόλαβε. Από τότε, κανένα άλλο σκάφος, υποβρύχιο ή επιφανείας, δεν έλαβε αυτό το όνομα.


Το P311 απέπλευσε από τη Μάλτα στο τέλος του Δεκεμβρίου του 1942. Ήταν η πρώτη αποστολή του, μια πολύ δύσκολη επιχείρηση, σχεδόν αποστολή αυτοκτονίας. Ο στόχος ήταν φιλόδοξος: Να φτάσει στο λιμάνι της La Maddalena και να βυθίσει με τα μίνι-υποβρύχια τα Ιταλικά πολεμικά σκάφη που βρίσκονταν εκεί.


Λίγες μέρες μετά τον απόπλου του ωστόσο, στις αρχές Ιανουαρίου του 1943, το P311 προσέκρουσε σε νάρκη που δεν απέχει πολύ από την Tavolara.


Λέγεται ότι κάποιοι ψαράδες είχαν ακούσει ένα δυνατό βουητό, σαν έκρηξη, κατά τη διάρκεια μιας θυελλώδους νύχτας, ωστόσο κανένας κατά τη διάρκεια των επόμενων δεκαετιών δεν ήταν ποτέ σε θέση να εντοπίσει το βρετανικό υποβρύχιο, μέχρι τη στιγμή που ο Μποντόνε αντίκρυσε ένα μοναδικό θέμα σε βάθος που άγγιζε τα 80 μέτρα, κάτω από την επιφάνεια της θάλασσας.


Την περασμένη Κυριακή, ωστόσο, στις 22 Μαϊου του 2016 ο Μάσιμο Μποντόνε εντόπισε, μόλις μερικά χιλιόμετρα από τον Κόλπο της Olbia το σχεδόν άθικτο ναυάγιο.


Το P311, με 84 μέτρα μήκος και 8 μέτρα πλάτος αναπαύεται στο βυθό της θάλασσας, σχεδόν άθικτο.

Μόνο η πλώρη έχει υποστεί ζημιά, λόγω της έκρηξης της νάρκης.


Το πυροβόλο μπροστά από τον πυργίσκο είναι ένα ακόμη σημάδι. Τα δύο μίνι-υποβρύχια κάνουν την ταυτοποίηση σχεδόν βέβαια!

Η ανακάλυψη είναι πολύ σημαντική επίσης, καθώς το P311 είναι η τελευταία κατοικία του πληρώματος, καθώς βυθίστηκε αύτανδρο, χωρίς κανείς να καταφέρει να διασωθεί: 61 μέλη του πληρώματος και 8 χειριστές των μίνι-υποβρυχίων, μαζί με δύο μηχανικούς, σύνολο 71 ναυτικοί που δε γύρισαν ποτέ στη βάση τους. 


"Πρέπει να αντιμετωπίζουμε τέτοια ναυάγια με απόλυτο σεβασμό" τόνισε ο Μάσιμο Μποντόνε στην εφημερίδα "La Nuova Sardegna".

"Η ζωή σε ένα υποβρύχιο ήταν πραγματικά πολύ δύσκολη, οι μικροί χώροι ενδιαίτησης, οι κακές συνθήκες διαβίωσης και ο συνεχής φόβος μήπως χτυπηθεί από μια τορπίλη ή μια βόμβα βυθού", πρόσθεσε ο έμπειρος Ιταλός δύτης. 


Το Ρ311 εντάχθηκε στο 10ο στολίσκο υποβρυχίων στη Μάλτα τον Νοέμβριο του 1942 και χάθηκε αύτανδρο μεταξύ της 30ής Δεκεμβρίου 1942 και 8ης Ιανουαρίου 1943, ενώ κατευθυνόταν προς την εκπλήρωση της πολεμικής του αποστολής στη La Maddalena της Σαρδηνίας.

Ένα μήνυμα που έλαβε ο Μάσιμο Μποντόνε από ένα μέλος της οικογένειας ενός εκ των χαμένων ναυτικών έχει ως εξής:


«Κύριε Μποντόνε, εξ ονόματος της οικογένειας του ναυτικού Λ. Ότι, θα ήθελα να σας ευχαριστήσω για τον εντοπισμό του υποβρυχίου HMS P311 και τον σεβασμό που δείξατε σε αυτούς που χάθηκαν. Έχετε την ευγνωμοσύνη και το σεβασμό μου."

Δίνοντας στις οικογένειες τη δυνατότητα να γνωρίζουν τον τόπο που αναπαύονται οι χαμένοι συγγενείς τους μετά από 73 χρόνια είναι, κατά τη γνώμη μου, το πιο σημαντικό στοιχείο αυτής της ιστορικής ανακάλυψης του Μάσιμο Μποντόνε.

Πέμπτη 26 Μαΐου 2016

FOUND! The final resting place of Tutankhamen: HMS P311, the British WW2 submarine lost with 71 sailors is located and identified by Italian scuba diver Massimo Domenico Bondone


Underwater photos: Massimo Domenico Bondone and Orso Diving

Massimo "Max" Domenico Bondone, an experienced deep diver and explorer from Italy is credited with yet another fascinating wreck find and identification.

Massimo Domenico Bondone, is a fan of wreck diving and over the years he is credited with some historic finds: He has found S/S Kreta, near the island of Capraia, Benghazi in Sardinia  and San Marco off Villasimius among other wrecks. 


A British submarine, lost for 73 years, since 1943, was found by Massimo Domenico Bondone and positively identified, thanks to a unique feature: Two Chariots, small assault submarines, piloted by two people, who easily could creep into enemy ports and place underwater explosive charges on enemy shipping. 

Luca Magliacca, Domenico Massimo Bondone and Corrado Azzali


The midget submarines were still there, attached to the hull of P311 or "Tutankhamen", as this was the name the submarine would be assigned, after the Egyptian king. She would have been the only vessel of the Royal Navy, before or since, to officially bear the name, but never did.

Loading torpedoes on P311 at Holy Loch, Scotland, 1942
The Class T HMS P311 had left Malta at the end of December 1942. It was her first mission, a very difficult one, almost suicidal. The goal was ambitious: to reach the port of La Maddalena to hit Italian cruisers Trieste and Gorizia.


But a few days later, in early January 1943, the P311 struck a mine not far from Tavolara. 

It is said that some fishermen have heard a loud roar, during a stormy night. But none over the decades had never been able to locate the British submarine. 


Last Sunday however, on May 22nd, 2016 Massimo Domenico Bondone discovered a few kilometers from the Gulf of Olbia the nearly intact wreck.

The P311,  84 meters long and  8 meters wide lies at the seabed, almost intact. 


Only the bow is damaged, because of the explosion of the mine. 

The silhouette of a cannon positioned in front of the turret is yet another sign. The two Chariots make the identification almost certain!



The discovery is exceptional and very important too, as the P311 is considered to be the final resting place of her crew, as all hands were lost with her: 61 crew members and 8 operators of the two Chariots with two engineers.




In all probability the middle compartments of the submarine were not flooded, as the explosion of the mine could not have affected the internal structure, which has remained sealed since January 1943.



"We must treat such wrecks with utmost respect" Massimo Domenico Bondone said to the newspaper "La Nuova Sardegna"



"Life in a submarine was really very difficult, including tight spaces, poor living conditions and the constant fear of being hit by a torpedo or a depth charge", Massimo Domenico Bondone added.



HMS P311 was a T-class submarine of the Royal Navy, the only boat of her class never to be given a name. She was to have received the name Tutankhamen but was lost before this was formally done.



The Prime Minister, Winston Churchill had minuted the Admiralty on 5 November 1942, 19 December and again on 27 December, saying that all submarines should have names. In the final minute, he provided a list of suggestions and insisted that all unnamed submarines be given names within a fortnight. 



P311 was to be assigned the name Tutankhamen, after the Egyptian king. She would have been the only vessel of the Royal Navy, before or since, to bear the name. She was lost in the Mediterranean between late December 1942 or early January 1943, before the new name could be formally assigned. 

She therefore never received the name Tutankhamen, and is officially designated as P311.



P311 was a Group 3 T-class boat built by Vickers-Armstrong at Barrow-in-Furness and commissioned on 5 March 1942 under the command of Lieutenant R.D. Cayley. She was one of only two T-class submarines completed without an Oerlikon 20 mm anti-aircraft gun, the other being HMS Trespasser.





She joined the 10th Submarine Flotilla at Malta in November 1942, and was lost with all hands between 30 December 1942 and 8 January 1943 whilst en route to La Maddalena, Sardinia where she was to attack two Italian 8-inch gun cruisers using Chariot human torpedoes carried on the casing as part of Operation Principle.



She was reported overdue on 8 January 1943 when she failed to return to base. She was mined and sank near the island of Tavolara, in Sardinia.



A message Massimo Domenico Bondone received from a family member of one of the lost seamen reads as follows:

"Sir on behalf of the family of Able Seaman L Auty, I would like to thank you for finding HMS P311 and the care and respect that you have shown to those that perished. You have my grateful respect."

Giving the lost seamen's families closure, to help them know where they loved ones are after 73 years, is the most important element of this discovery, in my opinion.